Systems dynamics meets the Afghan war via Powerpoint
what if someone made a slide of a zoom in on the surface of a semi-conductor chip?
Wouldn’t that seem as incomprehensible and “foolish”? and yet by the slow process of developing knowledge we have become capable of extraordinary things enabled by semiconductors and information theory
It was much busier than that slide. And yet somehow that very complex model yielded important insights related to the management of complexity in a way that transcended simple rules of cause and effect.
Complexity requires new forms of building and communicating understanding and appreciation, which cannot be easily transmitted through the linear text modes favored by those who want to see a return to management by info papers only.
It would take many books to flesh out a detailed description of what that one slide is already able to represent in a single image, admittedly busy.
Does anyone think war in Afghanistan is any less complex than the slide indicates? If anything, it’s absurdly simplistic.
In any event, developing models of complexity is exactly how you go about making the unknown a little more knowable.
A systems dynamics model is the first step towards building collaborative understanding of complexity.
We laugh about the 6 blind men trying to describe the elephant, but we forget that after each has shared his limited experience of the elephant, we are left with a pretty good list of what qualities the elephant actually has, and those 6 blindmen collectively know more about elephants together than they did individually.
that’s what that slide says to me.
And those who would eliminate Powerpoint on principle are apparently making the argument that visual learning and graphics degrade communication.
Like any other tool (Powerpoint, not me) I am against the misuse of Powerpoint in the classroom or in decision making.
I acknowledge that it is all too easy to confuse activity (including “busy” slides) with results
But I also know of excellent resources broadly available that make visual display of information a communication multiplier:
Cliff Atkinson: Beyond Bullet Points
Edward Tufte: everything he has ever written
Seth Groden: many things he has written
Related articles by Zemanta
- Cartoon: Captive Audiences (readwriteweb.com)
- Discuss: Powerpoint is the enemy? (flowingdata.com)
- Microsoft’s PR Department Must Be Shitting Their Pants Right Now (slog.thestranger.com)
- Enemy Lurks in Briefings on Afghan War – PowerPoint – NYTimes.com (nytimes.com)
- Misleading Image for Army: New York Times, PowerPoint and Complexity Fail (AuthenticOrganizations.com)
- Enemy Lurks in Briefings on Afghan War: PowerPoint (nytimes.com)
- We Have Met the Enemy and He Is PowerPoint (nytimes.com)
- Pecha Kucha Presentation Zen (slideshare.net)
- The Deadly Decks of Afghanistan (windsofchange.net)
- PowerPoint is making us stupid, says U.S. military commander (thestar.com)
- How important is contextual knowledge for process consultants in business settings? (kansasreflections.wordpress.com)
- Complexity in process consulting: a good thing? (kansasreflections.wordpress.com)
- The Pentagon’s Revolving Door: When Theory Meets Reality (usacac.army.mil)
- Reflecting on the Art and Science of Sustainment in Army Education (usacac.army.mil)
- F100: (Force Management): why we teach it (usacac.army.mil)
- Army Enterprise Task Force: potentially greatest in-house management re-organization ever (usacac.army.mil)
- Update on the Force Generation wiki and Student Text 525 (usacac.army.mil)
- A thought experiment for revolutionary leadership (usacac.army.mil)
- “CGSC “Future Force” management game (filled with creamy ARFORGEN goodness) (usacac.army.mil)